[PDF / Epub] ✑ Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy ☄ Josef Steiff – Horse-zine.co.uk


Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy quotes Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy , litcharts Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy , symbolism Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy , summary shmoop Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy , Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy 94f81c8d This Entertaining Collection Of Essays Deserves To Exist Because Sherlock Holmes Sees Things Others Don T He Sees The World In A Different Way, And By So Doing, Allows Us To See That Same World And Human Behavior In Different Ways As Well Oh, Sure, There Have Been Countless Detectives Who Have Followed In His Footsteps And Who Seem To Rival His Abilities Just Turn On The TV Or Browse The Local Bookshop And You Ll Find Idiosyncratic Super Sleuths Using Forensics And Reasoning To Solve A Whole Host Of Crimes And Misdeeds And Yet No One Rivals Our Dear, Dear Holmes Why Does Sherlock Reign, Even Than A Century Later, As King Can This Mystery Be Solved Unable To Reach Either Holmes Or Watson Or Doyle For That Matter, Though We Ve Tried Every Medium We Can Think Of , We Ve Been Forced To Gather Our Own Team Of Investigators To Practice Their Powers Of Observation And Perception, To Apply Their Own Reasoning And Methodologies To The Task At Hand The Results, I Fear, Have Led Us To A Number Of Cases That Must Be Solved FirstIs Holmes Simply Eccentric Or A Sociopath S He Human, A Dog Or Something From The Holodeck Is He As Dangerous On The Page As He Is In Person Wait Does He Even Exist For That Matter, Do You I Fear Several Investigators Have Been Forced To Take A Much Needed Holiday After Wrestling With That One What Is The Source Of His Faculty Of Observation And Facility For Deduction Systematic Training As Watson Surmises Genetic Or Is He Just Really Lucky And Is This Whole Logic Thing Compatible With Emotions Are Holmes And Watson Good Friends Or Soul Mates Just What Is The Nature Of Friendship Do They Complete Each Other Or Just Get On Each Other S Nerves And Why All The Secrecy Disguises Deceptions The Plot Thickens What Is The Essence Of Consciousness Is The Observable World Subject To Our Intentions Why Does Holmes Debunk Mysticism When Doyle So Readily Embraces It Why Is Holmes Our Favorite Drug User Our Notebooks Are Filled With Clues And, Dare I Say, Answers Is There Than One Way To Define The Concept, Justice Is Hope Necessary In The World Is Boredom Play Can Any Thing Really Be Understood Objectively And Just What Is The Last Unresolved Mystery Involving Sherlock Holmes The Game That S Afoot Isn T Just The Thing Being Pursued But The Fun To Be Had As Well


10 thoughts on “Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy

  1. says:

    Sherlock Holmes and Philosophy is a fun read for any Holmes fan The book is part of the Popular Culture and Philosophy series and contains 33 short chapters broken up into 7 categories The amateur detectives authors deal with all sorts of topics about Sherlock Holmes including discussions of philosophers and theories, summations of cases, several folks pick their favourite Holmes actor and give reasons why, there are chapters on the development of the detective genre, Moriarty, virtual reality, and how Holmes adjusted to married life to name a few The book deals with all sorts of Holmes issues the official Doyle canon, the non canonical Doyle stories, pastiches, television, theater, and film including Star Trek and Japanese manifestations, and modern fiction.


  2. says:

    I think my problem with this book is that I m not the right audience for it I struggled with this I mean, I wrote my master s thesis on Sherlock Holmes Questioning whether Mycroft or Sherlock is the smarter Holmes, wondering how Holmes would adapt to marriage, and trying to determine once and for all if Holmes and Watson have a mutually respectful friendship is, to me, kinda undergrad ish I find it kinda cheesy that legit scholars including some of the ones contributing to this book pretend that Holmes was a real person, and that Watson was his editor using Conan Doyle s name as a nom de plume I m interested in how the Holmes phenomenon from its original stories to the recent movie and TV adaptations have shaped been shaped by pop culture I d like to read about Holmes methodology in the context of detective fiction as a genre How did Holmes as a character influence the unsympathetic hero trope There are flashes of this here, like Round s juxtaposition of Holmes and TV s Dr House, and ideas of masculinity in her Out of House and Holmes, but not enough to sustain my attention.


  3. says:

    To see the Genius of this character, to wonder at the impact he made to society and culture, to unveil the influence he had in the modern era and to continuously be relevant and keep up with the timesI think Sherlock Holmes is indeed a genius and this book provides an illumination on the hows and whys based on the imprints of his mind This book is equally as brilliant as the man it investigates.


  4. says:

    If you re into Sherlock Holmes and consider yourself his number one fan this might be the book for you Is the relationship between Watson and Holmes a good one Why does Sherlock Holmes use cocaine Is Mycroft smarter than Sherlock and if so, why These questions and much are answered


  5. says:

    Another in the Open Court Pop Culture and Philosophy books This one tackling the great detective Sherlock Holmes As usual it consists of an anthology of essays, vaguely organized into themes.The offerings are perhaps inevitably focused on issues of good reasoning, inferring truth from evidence, solving mysteries and the like In this though there is a diversity of models of good reasoning and a diversity of opinions about where Holmes genius could lie, philosophical models of good reasoning and Holmes genius come variously from Spinoza, Heidegger, Pierce, Hume and Mill according to different authors Other issues in ethics, is Holmes right to exercise his discretion in enforcing the law and other topics such as the role of scientific reasoning in order our lives are also discussed some based on analytical arguments, some intuitive and some emotional Most essays are about the canonical Holmes stories, but others focus on later adaptations and references to Holmes from Star Trek to House A few of the essays seem to be exercises in compiling literary facts of things like the Holmes cannon or some adaption of the detective rather than a philosophical investigation of such issues.The citation system or rather the lack of it leaves something to be desired if you are trying to follow up on exactly what these authors are taking from others.All and all a fun exploration of Holmes and use of the material to make a few arguments, but not a rigorous or comprehensive exercise.


  6. says:

    Many viewpoints and many Holmesian moments rememberedPhilosophy for many, myself included, goes down much readily when taken with a liberal dose of sweetener in this instance, fondly remembered moments of adventure with the world s greatest detective Facts from Holmes s cases and sayings illuminate opinions of other great thinkers, from Socrates to Nietzsche.


  7. says:

    568 2019


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *